Sunday, August 22, 2010

Final Project :) - Congrats everyone, has been a fantastic few weeks !







AID FOR SMILES : PROJECT MANAGEMENT FINAL ASSIGNMENT

Name of Project Manager: Jessica Kapralik

Project Title: Break the Cycle

Project Location:
In field: Wa, Ghana
Off field: Hamilton, Canada

Project duration: September 2010 – January 2011

Total Project Cost in CAN $: $950 + $3765 x volunteer

Project Background/Need statement/Problem Analysis:

The communities in which this project would be implemented are the impoverished areas situated around Wa, Ghana. Similar to many areas of Africa this region has a high prevalence of HIV/AIDS and malaria among other diseases. This is due to a number of factors such as a lack of health care and medication and poor health status and malnutrition among others. What results from the high prevalence of illness is a never ending cycle of poverty leading to disease which creates a population lacking the energy and physical ability to be productive leading to further poverty.
This project would aim to break this cycle in a way that is sustainable, preventing it starting again when the project is no longer present in the community. Other organizations and projects have attempted to address the problem of disease and its effects through the provision of medicines, as it is a natural response to disease for those with the resources to afford them. However often these projects have been faced with obstacles surrounding cultural insensitivity and lack of adherence as the regimes are formed to suit the developed world in which they are produced. What has resulted is failed projects, frustrated project managers and even worse complications in terms of mistrust by the communities and resistance to medication.
This project would take a different approach to the problem in that instead of focusing on treatment of disease, it would focus on prevention. These types of projects, like condom provision and promotion projects for HIV/AIDS and mosquito bed net supplying projects for malaria, address the problem of disease starting at the root cause and thus generally very effective. As this project would arm people with an immune system capable of fighting disease and its ill affects it would apply to a wide range of diseases and communities. It would also be sustainable because the immune system and over all health status, once built up, would help a population reach levels of productivity that will help them break out of the poverty cycle by resisting the exhaustion and weakness resultant of disease.
The project would consist of the provision and monitoring of nutritional supplements focusing on those benefitting the body’s ability to fight disease. These supplements have a less strict regime than more intensive medications and because they are restoring naturally present substances they are more culturally acceptable than interventions such as condoms. Nutritional supplements are also very cost effective in comparison to drugs like ARVs and therefore can be supplied more easily to the masses. The fact that they are flexible in terms of storage and transportation also makes them an ideal intervention for projects looking to address disease. Unfortunately many conventional medical professionals feel that nutrition alone isn’t enough to eradicate disease. Studies have shown that it is however more than sufficient to reverse many of the effects of disease enabling people to work, attend school and essentially break the cycle that resulted in their illness in the first place.

Baseline Project Information:

The baseline project information will essentially be a compilation of literary research and in-field observations and research. Prior to planning this project a great deal of research on global health issues especially in regards to disease and poverty has been completed. Of course all research indicates the disease and poverty cycle to be a primary problem, in itself as well as in the context of certain nations’ slow progression in achieving the milestones needed to develop. The literature also that, as was stated above, disease and poverty work in a cyclical nature to impede populations from maximizing their ability to pursue education and employment creating nations lacking in the labour force essential to their productivity. The intervention proposed by the project aims to address this problem through the creation of a population unhindered by disease (or substantially less hindered) so that the nation’s productivity and consequent development is not impeded by ever-present illness. This was based on research which both indicates the weaknesses of treatment-based disease interventions as well as the need for an inexpensive and environmentally / culturally appropriate means of combating the effects of widespread disease. As prevention-based projects have historically been very effective this projects aims to intervene in a similar manner, addressing disease before it is a problem for the individual. Fighting malnutrition and its effects, especially in the context of immune function, does exactly this and the review by () on intervention with seleniomethionine supplements, indicates that it can be an extremely effective means to combating disease.
An effective project however cannot be built on literature alone, and there any a great number of environmental, cultural and community-specific factors that can determine its success or failure.To address this, the primary objective of the project will be to establish a more comprehensive baseline from which to measure the effectiveness of the project. Obtaining this will be done through in-field evaluations consisting of personal observation of the environment by participants, interviews of the beneficiaries focusing on determining a general health status for the focus population (both physical, emotional and mental) as well as data on school and work attendance, dietary norms and medical information (maintaining respect for each individuals privacy).
The analysis and compilation of literary review and in-field research will allow the project participants to develop a baseline understanding of the communities’ health status and the factors that are foremost in determining it. From this they can then assess the likelihood of the projects success and make needed modifications before implementation. It also provides a baseline from which to measure progress in terms of improving health, energy and productivity of the beneficiaries involved to ensure the project stays “on track” in terms of reaching its objectives and overall aim.

Project Summary/Description:

The Break the Cycle Project will aim to provide, promote and monitor the use of nutritional supplements, specifically seleniomethionine supplements, to the community residents around Wa, Ghana. These supplements will work against the devastating effects malnutrition takes on the immune system of these residents, allowing their bodies to form and strengthen their own host defenses against disease and illness. By addressing disease we hope to improve the overall health and energy levels of those involved, giving them the energy and strength to pursue education or employment and work to better not only their own situation but contribute to the development and prosperity of their community and their country.
Provision of Supplements: The project will purchase and transport Nutramiracle supplements to Wa, Ghana eliminating the monetary burden of purchasing own medication that has proven an obstacle to other projects in the provision of medications or other resources.
Promotion of Supplements: The project will properly distribute two weeks worth of the supplements pre-measured and packaged (bottles or bister packs depending on funding) to those wish to be involved in the project.
Monitoring of the Supplements: Every two weeks when the participants return for their next dosage they will be asked to participate in an interview and medical check-up (their choice to not participate in either of these aspects of the project will be honoured). The data obtained will be used to evaluate the progression of the project. Food and drink will be offered at these clinics to help encourage attendance.

Project Goal/Aim:

The overall aim of this project is to contribute to breaking the cycle between disease and poverty that hinders development in the impoverished areas of the world. Through counteracting the negative effects of malnutrition and restoring a state of health to individuals making them less vulnerable to illness it increase participation in the labour force. This can help increase the productivity within these nations and their ability to pursue development.

Project Objectives:

These objectives are the most primary in developing the project. Further project objectives regarding applying for funding, obtaining supplements and the like will be planned and timed according to the success of these original objectives. Therefore the specifics of objectives regarding volunteer training, funding and supplement purchasing will be determined in January 2011 after evaluation of the initial project stages.

  • In September -December 2010 determine the approximate number of people aged 3-25 years living in the communities of Wa suffering from malnutrition and/or disease and a baseline health status for this group in terms of physical health, emotional health and energy level.
  • In September-December 2010 determine the average number days a typical student aged 5-18 (ages up for modification upon arrival in the field) in Wa misses due to illness (directly- being ill themselves or indirectly – due to a family member’s illness)
  • In September- December 2010 determine the 10 primary foods in the diet of the residents of Wa
  • By the end of January 2011 know each foods selenium level, other nutritional value and any potential more nutritional alternatives
  • By December 2010 recruit at least 2 other people to participate in the project (age at least 18)
Project Activities:

Stage 1- Establishment and Baseline Development (September 2010 – December 2010)

In the initial stages of project implementation it will need to first establish a foundation in the community. This will require travelling to the community, meeting the chiefs, beneficiaries and their families to begin developing a sense of familiarity and trust between people that is vital to a successful project. Ghana is categorized as an English speaking country but for the comfort and ease of both the beneficiaries and volunteer community members willing to serve as communication links and interpreters will also be hired.Following this the primary research must be conducted. This will consist of short interviews with community members asking questions concerning their levels of energy, school or work attendance and diet focusing not only on what their problems are but on why they occur. One important piece of information needed to be obtained is how many people would be interested in participating in the supplement regime. Accompanying this will be interview with teachers discussing attendance and the prevalence of disease in the school setting. It would be ideal that some form of medical check-up could be performed for those willing to participate but this will be dependent on cooperation of those involved and the resources available in terms of medical personel and materials.

Stage 2 – Data Analysis and Project Planning Part II (Part I being what in included in this paper)

In this stage the data collected throughout stage one will be reviewed and analyzed. Analysis will look at picking out what the main problems are concerning the health status of this group and the consequences are of these problems (Eg disease causing poor school attendance or malnutrition causing lack of energy for participation in the community). After isolating these central themes the factors contributing to them will attempted to be determined and these will serve as the focus of the project, primarily those involving disease and nutrition.
Based on the conclusions drawn from the data analysis the project will be re-evaluated and modifications to better suit the community and setting will be made (such as a different nutrient supplement if it is found selenium isn’t as deficient as another nutrient, or a different time period for monitoring). Following this the specifics of the project will be solidified including training volunteers in what their new responsibilities will be, pursuing funding and sourcing out the most suitable nutrition supplements to use.


Stage 3 – Implementation, Monitoring and Re-evaluation

Returning to the community the same activities of meeting and establishing relations with the chiefs and community members will be required first. Following this the individuals originally expressing interest in participating in the project will be asked if they are still willing to participate and it will be opened to those in the community also interested. Once the participants are determined the supplements will be given in 2 week doses and asked to return the day they take their last supplement. When they return a short interview similar to the initial one will be conducted as well as medical checkups (if permitted) to monitor any effects of the supplements. This regime will continue for 3 months (in the event of sufficient funding) if it is observed to be beneficial to those involved.

Stage 4 – Evaluating Results and Reporting

The data obtained from the biweekly interviews and checkups will be reviewed to determine the effectiveness of the project and where its strengths and weaknesses are. All raw data as well as a summary of the project will be drawn up and submitted to the Global Health department of McMaster University for potential continuance of the project.
If successful it may also be submitted to other organizations and supplement companies to obtain further funding or donations and support to continue this project in other regions.


Project Timeline: See 3 Corresponding Tables Above

Description of Project Beneficiaries:

The beneficiaries of the Break the Cycle project will be residents of the communities around Wa, Ghana. Age and gender are not as important to the project as willingness to participate and therefore will be less specific. Due to the requirements of the regime and evaluation process the beneficiaries will be required to be at least 8 years of age (subject to modification if needed) but there are no upper age restraints as long as the individual is capable of adhering to the regime ( even if resistance is required). The individuals the project aims to target are those suffering from malnutrition and illness (which illness is unspecific as the supplements target the general immune function) as it is these individuals that will benefit most from the supplements and will indicate whether they are an effective approach to addressing problems associated with the disease-poverty cycle.

Target Community Input and Collaboration:
The main material input that will be required from the community will be in supplying accommodations for the project volunteers in terms of homestays and communication aid. This will of course not be for free, proper monthly rent payments of an agreed upon amount will be made to the families and a daily wage will be given to those involved in interpreting for the volunteers and the community members.
In terms of their input contributing to the progression of the project it will be an aspect concentrated on during the biweekly interviews. The participants will be asked questions regarding whether they are experiencing problems with the project. These problems may be physical like side effects (though extremely uncommon with properly taken nutritional supplements) or situational if the supplement regime is difficult for community members to adhere to due to their particular life style.
The other source of community input is essentially in the collaboration with the grassroots organization True Vision Ghana. This has allowed the primary project planning to be conducted with a better idea of the community we are aiming to benefit. As the creator of True Vision Ghana did much of the original organization required was completed in terms of choosing communities in need of aid, setting up a central office for volunteers to use as well as creating a website and establishing liaisons with other countries. True Vision Ghana created a structure through which the project can be better implemented than if we had attempted to do so ourselves upon arrival.
The project aims to eliminate as much of them physical burden as possible while building the project as it progresses to best suit the feedback they are receiving from the members so the project essentially starts with the community it aims to benefit.

Innovation:

This project is different from most other because it takes a very different approach to the problems of malnutrition and disease. More often the provision of food supplies is implemented in addressing malnutrition and medicine in addressing disease, however treating these two problems as mutually exclusive is a weakness in these problems as they are part of a cycle; one promoting the other. Food provision is of course beneficial, but supplying food with low nutritional value is unsustainable because it is addressing hunger not malnutrition. Likewise the provision of medicine, as stated previously, is often met with many obstacles like cultural barriers and cost and therefore can only be optimally effective in the right environment. This project takes a different approach by addressing the root cause underlying both malnutrition and disease: a deficiency in the nutrients important to immune function and general health maintenance.
The idea of supplying more directly the nutrients needed by the body to battle disease before it becomes a problem for the individual is a more alternative approach to health and therefore is often overlooked by the conventional medical world. However because it is completely natural it avoids some of the barriers faced by other medical interventions and has been found an extremely effective method of fighting diseases like HIV/AIDS.

Project Outcome:

The immediate outcome of the project are very simple, essentially just improved health allowing community members to attend school and work unhindered by a lack of energy and illness.

Project Sustainability:

The project will be sustainable for two reasons, its effects are long lasting and they induce further changes benefitting the community.
Providing nutrients to people, arms their immune system with what it needs to fight disease at its highest capacity. A small amount of nutrients can benefit a wide number of cells so that its affects compound. Building up the immune system in turn protects it from the strain put on it by ever-present illnesses, especially HIV/AIDS. Therefore the implementation of nutrient supplements takes advantage of the cyclic nature of the issues of malnutrition and disease creating instead a situation where improved nutrition promotes immune function which prevents disease and allows individuals to continue to better their situation and health.
The benefits are also sustainable because they reach past just that of the communities’ physical health. The improvement of health opens doors for greater growth providing people with increased energy and stronger bodies unhindered by illness. These individuals can then contribute to the development of their nation by attending school and work regularly building the human capital required for sustainable development.
Cycles are neverending; sustainable. This project aims to break one, replacing it with one leading to the betterment of the population and contribution to their communities and country.

Partnership/Stakeholders:

Initially the project will primarily be partnered with McMaster University and True Vision Ghana, but is open to involvement with anyone interested in pursuing the objectives of this project.
McMaster University has been and will continue to be the institution providing the foundation for the course. The university’s global health department studies and researches such issues and therefore offers knowledgeable professors and students to plan and participate in projects as well as resources to consult in planning and managing programs. Partnership with McMaster also provides a more acceptable name through which to apply for funding and donations and therefore is an invaluable asset to this project.
True Vision Ghana (TVG) is also incredibly important to the success of this project because it provides a better connection to the community in which the project will function. As TVG is a very grassroots NGO itself, working with them essentially means the project is beginning with the community it aims to benefit. They are essential to the planning process in ensuring the project is suited to the needs of the community and their environments as well as accommodations for the staff are confirmed so that this does not become an issue upon arrival hindering the programs commencement.
The combination of these two partnerships provides strong foundations both in and out of field so that no matter what stage of the project is being conducted it is environment-specific, well planned and resources are ready and available.

Communication and Sharing:

The project outcome will ideally be shared through a report which will be available to other organizations, schools and students worldwide (likely on the internet). It will be composed by the project staff after all stages have been completed, edited by the staff as well as students of the global health faculty at McMaster University, to the faculty for potential publishing on the faculty website.
Duplication of this project is not at all discouraged, though preferably it would not be duplicated in the same region. Hopefully the project, if successful, can be the foundations for the creation of a club that will plan to duplicate the project in a different region each year (or whatever it is next possible in terms of funding). This club could then encourage similar clubs to form at other schools creating essentially a fleet of young activists working to better the health of communities in need world-wide.

Project Management Structure:

The organization of management in this project would be based primarily on group contributions rather than individual authority. However, there will be positions on specific responsibility such as volunteer coordinator, data management chair, and two people chairing fundraising and donations. These people will each be responsible for specific tasks outside the typical responsibilities surrounding research in and out of field, project implementation and report writing among others (See corresponding table above).
Apart from the extra responsibilities the project will be group-based primarily running through group meetings. This allows each member to bring their unique strengths to the group that they may not have had the benefit of otherwise. Within this group, if a task arises requiring the division of tasks this will be done by the Project Manager and anything needing presenting to the group will be done through the volunteer coordinator who will collect the volunteers work prior to the meeting. This ensures that the Project Manager isn’t too authoritarian but the volunteers work is monitored and they have a central person through which they can communicate better with the rest of the team rather than having separate inquiries from all members continuously. Group meetings will also ensure all members have a chance to contribute to the project however they like sharing ideas and concerns and bettering the project unhindered by their status among the others.


Mobilizing Support:

This project hopes to initially pursue support from local communities through working with TVG. Through this partnership we hope to implement the project being as culturally sensitive as possible, gaining the trust and support of the communities involved. Those supplying services to the project in the form of accommodations or interpretation will be compensated with a weekly salary.
Community support of the project is most important in regards to adherence to the supplement regimes. How easily this will be done is difficult to foresee but, as the regimes are fairly simple, it should be easier than with more complex medicines. The project hopes to improve the likelihood of gaining full community support and cooperation by establishing trust and relationships within stage one of the project so that when they return in stage three to implement the supplements those foundations are already built to help support the aims of the project. This is a difficult aspect of the project and will require careful adjustments throughout project implementation to ensure the community remains involved and central in achieve the projects objectives.

Monitoring and Evaluation: See Corresponding Table Above

Challenges:

Problems that may arise concerning the implementation of this project mainly concern compliance. I understand and can identify with the fact that it is not comfortable to talk about personal information, especially with strangers, and therefore cooperation may be a concern. As it is important to obtain accurate qualitative data in order to ensure the program is addressing the predominant issues at hand preparations will need to be made. This may be approached through the use of anonymous journals, surveys or written-response type data collection technique so as to minimize the intrusion on personal privacy. A second major issue addresses the ethics of patient confidentiality. The information we can disclose with others involved in the program will be subject to the informed consent of the patient or of their parents depending on age. Addressing this, all information will be obtained under specific permissions and if necessary only presented to the rest of the group as general summaries of all the data collected by those individuals who obtained the dat (eg those conducting checkups and interviews). As well the implementation of supplements may not be received well by the population and therefore if the project as w whole is rejected by the population it will create large barriers to us determining how to modify the program to better suit their needs. The information acquired in stage one of the project should limit the likelihood of this occurring significantly however as their research should help foresee any problems as serious as this. Accompanying these are simply the barriers present when working abroad in terms of culture, language and illness that may present obstacles to those running the project and will have to be handled as they present themselves.

Financial Management Principles:

The primary principle in managing the projects finances is that everyone is active in budgeting and is aware of where money is being directed. As project manager I would feel most comfortable also acting as treasurer / financial manager because I feel it is too great a responsibility to force upon any other individual, if something were to go wrong I would feel more comfortable answering to myself. A separate bank account will be set up for the project’s funds and a log will be kept where any money put in or taken out of the account must be recorded indicating who took it out and for what reason and be signed off by both that person and myself. Prior to any moving of funds (with the exception of small purchase like supplies for meetings like food, pencils and paper) all expenditures must be discussed by the entire team to determine the importance of what is being bought, quantity needed, most cost effective place to purchase from and how much money the project can afford to expend in this area. All receipts will be kept in the back of the log book organized by month. Volunteer will be informed upon joining the project that it is likely they will be required to expend some funds for travel ( if they so choose to participate in stage 1 or 3) and therefore that aspect of funding will not be a group decision but will be the responsibility of the individual to obtain the funds needed in excess of those donated.

Fundraising:

As states in the financial management principles, at least initially, volunteers may have to contribute some of their own funds to the project and will be made aware of this upon application to join. It is not an ideal situation but as projects requiring travel can be costly, I would not want issues of funding to completely inhibit the project from progressing. However funding will still be sought out from institutions and organizations, especially those working with McMaster University or True Vision Ghana already (for example we recently acquired donations from a clothing company Entripy as well as their confirmation to partner with TVG). McMaster University will also be approached for support, especially if the project is successful in becoming a campus club which is entitled to certain funding opportunities. Accompanying these supplement companies will definitely be approached to hopefully secure donations or price-adjustments for the supplements used in the project as these are one of the more costly and important materials needed for the project to succeed. In return this company could gain an incredible reputation in global health and awareness, which is becoming increasing important as globalization becomes more and more a household name and therefore benefits the company as well as the project.
Apart from sourcing out partnerships and support small fundraisers like bake sales, car washes and the like are an excellent way to minimize the costs associated with running a project.

Budget Breakdown: See Corresponding Table Above

No comments:

Post a Comment